A debate club · A tech club · One society
A debate-and-publishing club about how technology affects the world — socially, economically, environmentally and geopolitically. You are handed a side, often not the one you hold, and you have to make it work.
Most school publications print one writer's view. Ours prints the argument that was actually had — both sides of it, sourced.
Tuesdays · Room 213 · September – November 2026 · BIS CAS club
The name
Why "Full Stack Society"
Full stack — The entirety of a computer system, from what is visible on the surface to the layers working beneath it. Every part plays a role, and each layer is the foundation for the next.
Society — A system of people, communities, institutions and structures that interact to shape how people live together.
Data centres and networks support platforms and apps, which support the things we touch every day — social media, banking, school, maps. Each layer is the foundation for the next, and we depend on all of them. We live in a full stack society. So we debate from the bottom up: understand the layers, connect them, then argue about what happens at the surface.
- Individuals How all of this shapes the choices people make.
- Society Behaviour, relationships, education, culture.
- Institutions How schools, governments and companies respond.
- Economics The businesses and incentives behind the technology.
- Infrastructure The networks and platforms that make it possible.
- Technology How smartphones, algorithms and platforms are designed.
The loop
How one session becomes a publication
- 01 Debate Two teams take a contested technology question. Sides are assigned, not chosen.
- 02 Film One of the leads films the whole debate and moderates it live, keeping it on the motion, while the other debates. Nobody takes notes.
- 03 Assess Afterwards the leads watch the footage back and score every debater on the rubric.
- 04 Publish The leads write the debate up from the recording as an 800–1,200 word brief: two positions, two sources each. At the end of term the briefs and the members' research paper make the club magazine.
Nine sessions of this loop — five briefs, a research paper, a magazine, and a signed record for every member.
The format
A structure you will know by week one
- 10 min Team prep
Sides are assigned, not chosen. You may be arguing against yourself. - 4 min each Opening statements
Each team lays out its case uninterrupted. - Untimed Crossfire
Open exchange — everyone in the room gets a turn. - 2 min each Closing statements
Last word for each side. - Afterwards Assessment
The leads score each debater from the footage. The highest total is Most Valuable Debater.
The whole debate is filmed. The leads score it from the footage afterwards, and the published brief is written from the same recording.
Latest brief
-
Should AI companies be allowed to train on copyrighted material without permission?
Is an AI model learning from a picture the same as an artist looking at one — and if it is, why does it matter that the artist is a person and the AI is a company?
Contributors: Aayan (moderator)
Three measurable goals · by 24 November 2026
Countable, dated and evidenced
12 / 6
Publish
Five debate briefs of 800–1,200 words, written up by the leads, and one research paper written by the members — every brief presenting at least two opposing positions with at least two cited sources per position.
67%
Participate
Every member completes at least two debate appearances as a speaker and contributes to the research paper.
Not yet
Magazine out
The five briefs and the research paper compiled into one club magazine, released on the website and social media.
Live figures, computed from what is actually published. Full report on the Contributors page.
Topic bank
What we argue about
Twelve questions on the slate. Members voted the term's topics in Session 1.
- Banning smartphones in schools
- AI and entry-level jobs
- Who should pay for e-waste
- Platform liability for minors
- Regulating tech we cannot understand
- Self-sufficiency vs global supply chains
- Progress: more resilient or more dependent
- The greatest smartphone company ever
- Should we be polite to AI
- Disclosing state AI suppliers
- Should the dark web exist
- AI-generated work in schools
