The archive
Briefs
Every debate, written up by the members who argued it. Each brief presents at least two opposing positions, and each position cites at least two sources.
-
Should AI companies be allowed to train on copyrighted material without permission?
Is an AI model learning from a picture the same as an artist looking at one — and if it is, why does it matter that the artist is a person and the AI is a company?
Contributors: Aayan (moderator)
-
Should space exploration be left to private companies rather than governments?
Both sides agreed SpaceX moves faster than NASA — the argument was over whether speed is what space exploration needs, or whether its real value is the kind no company can sell.
Contributors: Angelo (moderator)
-
Should governments be able to access encrypted messages to fight crime?
Both sides accepted that police can search a suspect with a warrant — the fight was over whether governments should be able to look before anyone is suspected.
Contributors: Dwij (moderator)
-
Samsung vs. Apple: who makes 'better' devices overall?
One side measured 'better' by choice, price and specs; the other by how well the whole thing works together — and the room never agreed which yardstick counts.
Contributors: Aayan (moderator)
-
Can addictive design ever be ethical?
“Is it ever ethical for companies to design technology that is intentionally addictive?”
Both sides agreed habit-forming design can hurt people — the argument was over who answers for it: the company that builds it, or the users and parents who decide how it gets used.
Contributors: Angelo (moderator)
-
Should internet service be nationalized?
One side argued about who gets connected; the other about who holds the off switch — and the debate turned on whether those are the same question.
Contributors: Angelo (moderator)