How we publish

Editorial standards

We publish disagreement, and disagreement is only worth reading if both sides are sourced. These are the rules every brief on this site has passed. Some of them are enforced by the website itself: a brief that breaks them will not build.

1. Both sides, every time

A brief presents at least two opposing positions, written to be as strong as each other. If one side reads weaker than the other, the editor sends it back. The writer's own opinion does not appear in either position. It can appear in the framing note at the top, clearly labelled as the writer's.

2. Two sources per side, minimum

Every position cites at least two sources, each with a title and a working link so a reader can check it. We prefer primary sources — the report, the dataset, the law — over articles about them. A source that cannot be linked cannot be used. The site refuses to build a brief with fewer than two sources on any side.

3. Sides are assigned

Debaters do not choose which side they argue. Nothing in a brief should be read as a debater's personal view. We say so on every brief, because readers who know a debater will otherwise assume it.

4. Every claim is checked before it goes live

A named fact-checker opens every link and confirms it says what the brief says it says. Figures, dates, names and quotations are checked against the source. A brief shows the date it was fact-checked. If a source turns out not to support the claim, the claim is cut — the argument is not softened to fit.

5. Corrections are visible, dated and never silent

If we get something wrong after publishing, we fix it and we say so. Each brief carries a corrections list showing what changed and when. We do not quietly edit published text. A reader who saw the original should be able to see the change.

To report an error, tell Angelo or Aayan at school.

6. Everyone is credited by name and role

Every brief lists who argued which side and which lead moderated, wrote, edited, fact-checked and designed it. This is partly fairness and partly the point: the Contributors page is built from those credits and is the club's record for the CAS programme.

7. Awards are scored, not voted on a whim

After each debate the leads watch the recording and score every debater on four criteria, 1–5 each. The highest total is Most Valuable Debater:

  • Evidence quality — Used specific, sourced facts rather than assertion.
  • Responsiveness — Engaged the opponent's actual argument, not a weaker version of it.
  • Clarity — The audience could follow the reasoning without rewinding.
  • Conduct — No interrupting, no strawmanning, the moderator respected.

8. Arguments come from the room

Every argument in a brief was made by a member in Room 213 and is on the recording of that debate. Nothing is added afterwards that wasn't said. Sources are found to check what the debaters claimed, and a source counts only once it has been opened and read.