Session 3 · 22 September 2026

Can addictive design ever be ethical?

“Is it ever ethical for companies to design technology that is intentionally addictive?”

6 min read · 2 positions · 5 cited sources · Session recording

  • Technology
  • Economics
  • Individuals

Neither team defended exploiting people, and neither claimed habit-forming design is always harmless. The For team’s case was that engagement is a tool whose ethics depend on its purpose and its safeguards; the Against team’s was that a product built to be hard to put down undermines the very self-control those safeguards depend on.

The debate turned when it moved from YouTube to apps with weaker moderation. The For team argued that harm on those apps comes from misuse and from users lying about their age, not from intentional design; the Against team argued that a company which knows about a harm and lets it continue has made a choice. Angelo, moderating, pushed the Against team for a solution rather than only objections, which led to the strongest exchange of the afternoon: whether age checks and parental controls should be optional or built in by default. Ms Joanna then asked the room how it was defining “ethical,” and both teams settled on the same answer — moral principles most people accept — before disagreeing about whether companies or families should be held to them.

Angelo filmed and moderated. Every argument above was made in Room 213; the sources were found afterwards to check the claims the debaters made.

Sides in this debate were assigned, not chosen. Neither position below should be read as any debater's personal view. Our standards.

Yes — it can be ethical

Designing for engagement isn't wrong in itself; what matters is the purpose, the benefit and the safeguards around it.

Aayan opened by separating technology that is designed to be engaging from technology that is designed to exploit. Notifications, streaks, rewards and personalised recommendations are all built to bring people back, and excessive use can cause real harm, but the existence of that risk does not make the design unethical. What makes it unethical is deliberately exploiting users. His example was an education app that uses streaks, rewards and daily notifications to get a student practising maths every day: the company is building a habit on purpose, and the habit is good for the student.

Novak put the same idea as an old principle: the dose makes the poison. Something is not harmful just because too much of it can be. Aayan extended this into a comparison with medicine. Some medicines can create dependence, yet we don't call them unethical; we ask why they are used, what benefit they give, what safeguards surround them and what risks they carry. The For team argued technology should be judged the same way: if engagement helps someone learn, communicate, exercise, create or be productive, then encouraging regular use has a legitimate purpose. When the Against team asked what medicine had to do with technology, Aayan's answer was that a phone or a laptop is the same — good uses, harmful in excess.

Their next argument was control. Users can turn off notifications, set limits, take breaks or delete an app, and nobody is forced to watch short videos. Novak pointed out that a lot of what is on YouTube Shorts is educational, including science explainers, and that the platform has opened up new careers for creators who can be good role models. Aayan added that the big platforms have already built safeguards: TikTok, for example, gives every under-18 account a 60-minute daily limit by default, after which a passcode is needed to keep watching.

When the Against team moved the debate to Telegram and harmful material shared there, Aayan argued this was a different question. A messaging app that puts its users' privacy first, and relies heavily on users reporting abuse, is not a company intentionally designing something addictive; illegal content is misuse by bad actors. If an app checks users' ages — some now use face scanning — and a child lies to get past it, the fault lies with the person who lied. His comparison: if someone lies to a doctor to be prescribed a drug, we don't call the doctor unethical. And when it comes to children, the For team argued the first duty belongs to parents, just as it does with anything else harmful at home.

Finally, Novak pointed to YouTube as a company acting responsibly: it uses machine learning to help identify videos made for children, and on those videos it turns off comments and personalised ads. In closing, Aayan summed up the team's case: if a company has put real effort into safeguards that are strong enough, it is not responsible when someone deliberately gets around them.

Sources (3)

No — never ethical

A product built to be hard to put down takes away the very choice its defenders rely on.

Dwij and Kartikeya argued that when a company designs something to be addictive, the reason is profit, and the user's wellbeing comes second. Dwij's example was the notification itself: the same nudge that reminds a student to finish a lesson is used by digital slot machines to keep people gambling away what they have. The mechanism is identical; what changes is whose interests it serves. Casino machines are a well studied case — they are designed around maximising "time on device," and players describe being pulled into a trance-like zone where they keep playing for its own sake.

They also turned the For team's medicine comparison back on them. Medicine exists to treat illness, not to keep patients coming back, and if the For team accepts that too much of something is harmful, Dwij argued, that supports the Against case: companies should not be designing products to push people towards too much.

Their central argument was about freedom of choice. The For team's case leaned on users being able to turn things off. Dwij's answer was that addiction is exactly what takes that ability away: once someone is hooked, it becomes hard for them to decide whether to stop, and a choice you cannot really make is not freedom. Research backs the idea that this is a real effect, not just a figure of speech: one study of social media users estimated that self-control problems account for about 31% of their use. Branding content as kid-friendly, Dwij argued, does not change the fact that it is built to hold young people's attention for profit.

Kartikeya widened the debate beyond YouTube. Platforms, he argued, have a duty to keep what happens on them within limits, and apps where harmful and explicit material can be searched for and shared are failing young users. When the For team called that a mistake rather than a design choice, he asked who decides that a mistake is not intentional; Dwij added that if a company knows about a harm and allows it to carry on, that is a decision. Dwij pointed to news reports of young people being targeted on apps such as Discord and Telegram that do little to verify who their users are.

On safeguards, the Against team argued that optional ones are not enough. Parental controls only work if a parent knows they exist and switches them on, and they are often hard to find; if a platform cannot be made safe for young users by default, Kartikeya asked, why release it to the public that way? He also warned that stricter checks bring their own risk: a company holding everyone's ID or face scans becomes a target for hackers.

Dwij's closing statement brought it together: with great influence comes responsibility. Young people should not have to protect themselves from platforms deliberately designed to keep them engaged. Companies need accurate age checks, parental tools, screen-time controls and stronger protections for young users — and those measures must not just exist, but be properly implemented, reviewed and enforced. Profit, he argued, should never come at the cost of a young person's wellbeing.

Sources (2)

Who argued which side

Yes — it can be ethical

Aayan, Novak

No — never ethical

Dwij, Kartikeya

Most Valuable Debater, scored on the rubric from the recording: Dwij

Credits

NameRole

CAS learning outcomes

This piece is evidence toward:

  • LO5 Demonstrate the skills and recognise the benefits of working collaboratively.
  • LO7 Recognise and consider the ethics of choices and actions.

← All briefs